Disputes
What happens when a debtor disputes the debt or replies during recovery, and how to handle it in RobinReturn.
Last updated
If a debtor replies during recovery — to query the invoice, raise a dispute, or propose a payment arrangement — a reply by email pauses the automated chase so you can deal with it properly. A genuine dispute is best resolved before any court step.
What pausing means
When a debtor replies by email to one of the messages RobinReturn has sent, the reply is matched to the case and the automated escalation stops. The case does not move forward on its own while a dispute is open — you decide what to do next.
Two things are worth knowing:
- An out-of-office or other automated response is recorded on the case but does not pause the chase.
- A reply that reached you another way — by phone or by post — and that you record with Log a reply on the case does not pause the reminders unless you tick Pause active reminders while I follow up when you log it.
Handling a dispute
Understand the objection
Read what the debtor is actually disputing — the amount, whether the work was done, a missing credit note, or something else.
Check your evidence
Compare the objection against your records — the invoice, contract, proof of delivery and any correspondence. See Create a case for the evidence that helps.
Decide how to proceed
Resolve the dispute, agree a payment arrangement, or — if you believe the debt is properly owed — continue the recovery sequence.
A paused chase does not restart on its own. When the reminder schedule has stopped, the case shows a Chase paused prompt with a Resume chase button: resuming sends only the reminder(s) that were never actually sent and continues the schedule from there.
Why disputes matter before court
A county court claim assumes the debt is genuinely owed and undisputed in substance. Pursuing a genuinely disputed debt through a claim can be the wrong route. Resolving the dispute first, or taking independent advice, is usually the better path.
Legal information
This is general information, not legal advice. RobinReturn is not a law firm or a legal representative under CPR 2.3(1). If a dispute is complex or significant, consider independent legal advice.